Top 5 Fanboy Grievances: Superhero Movie Franchises

Posted on June 03, 2010
Views: 10,367

Subscribe to our newsletter

Advertisements

It is a given that translating comics to film will inevitably anger some of the most hardcore and passionate of the fan-base. What types of “creative” changes irk faithful followers the most? Frankly it doesn’t take much. It can be a subtle costume design change, the mysterious absence of a favorite villain…or perhaps the complete lack of the spirit of the original comic that actually made it worth reading IN THE FIRST PLACE!

Considering the decades worth of history behind many popular comics, it is no wonder that sometimes things can go askew for any title. Translation: The longer a comic runs the more easily it can be ruined on the big screen. Perhaps it's only appropriate that Hollywood continues this practice of savagely trashing our favorite heroes from one film to the next in their own cinematic franchises. How do they do this you ask? ...Let's take a look.

1.

Same Character – Different Face!

different face01

Recasting is the name of the game. Although this is done in other genres which generate sequels it seems to consistently plague many a superhero franchise. It is very evident in the original series of “Batman” films, which contained four entries and three different actors all playing the same lead role. Perhaps this could be considered to be some kind of statement, in that, the different actors and their mannerisms are analogous to Batman's deeply fractured psyche? Nah...it pretty much all came down to dollars and cents.

different face02

As the movie series progressed, fans were left jaded and confused. It’s clear that in order to become emotionally invested in a series, one has to connect with the lead character. And to do that, it would be nice to actually see the same actor in the role from film to film. Also, a decent (non-disastrous) script would have helped. The icing on the cake with the recasting issue in the Batman films is that it wasn’t just limited to the lead role but also supporting roles as well.

different face03

2.

Same Face – Different Character!

different character01

Harrison Ford rocked our faces as both Indiana Jones and Han Solo and nobody had a problem with that. Clearly there’s nothing wrong with the same actor playing different heroic roles, but it is a bit odd how frequently it seems to occur within the world of superhero franchises. Take Ryan Reynolds for example. He portrayed Hannibal King in “Blade: Trinity”, Deadpool in “X-Men Origins: Wolverine” and soon he’ll take on the iconic role of Hal Jordan in “Green Lantern”.

We here at WeirdWorm have nothing against the guy… Reynolds is a very capable actor. He was born to play the role of the wisecracking Deadpool (though Hollywood really dropped the ball on that one) and he was fine in Blade. He should fair well in Green Lantern as well but really - is there a shortage of male leads in Hollywood? We don’t know, maybe we should ask Chris Evans what he thinks…

different character02

3.

The Retcon

the retcon01

At this point it’s common knowledge that Spiderman 3 was a heap of discarded insect exoskeletons. So many things went wrong with that film that we could easily dedicate a whole article to its many flaws…and still not be able to cover everything. In the interest of time, let’s just discuss the infamous retcon issue involving Ben Parker and Sandman. “Retconning” for those of you who don’t know is the deliberate changing of previously established continuity in a fictional work. For the purposes of Spiderman 3, retconning came into play for seemingly bizarre and utterly unnecessary reasons.

the retcon02

Spiderman 3 shoved the fact that Sandman was actually the real killer of Ben Parker (Pete’s Uncle) down our throats despite the fact that we all saw contrary events unfold in the first film. Had Spiderman 4 gone forward, Vulture likely would have turned out to be the guy who sold Sandman the gun or Aunt Mae or something.

Why was this ham-fisted change made? Clearly the director Sam Raimi felt the need to add fuel to Spidey’s fire and perhaps give him more of a reason to want to battle Sandman and have his “vengeance”. What boggles the mind is that Spiderman already could have had a clear cut reason to battle Sandman – because he’s the bad-guy! However, Sandman’s bad-guy status was heavily muddled through his overly sympathetic character arc. Ironically, the film was so hindered by subplots and excess characters that the classic comic-book version of Sandman may actually have helped the film.

Advertisements
Random
Page 1 of 3
Loading...

Latest Articles

20 Bizarre Flavors of Food You’ll Find Around the World

20 Bizarre Flavors of Food You’ll Find Around the World

People all over the world have different tastes in all sorts of things. Music, movies, television, politics, and so forth. And in some cases, it’s their actual tastes that vary...

20 of the Most Terrifying Things Kids Have Ever Said

20 of the Most Terrifying Things Kids Have Ever Said

Kids say the darndest things, as the old saying goes. They also say some of the most horrifying things, as well. Most of the time it’s just because they don’t know any better...

20 Creepiest Abandoned Hospitals From Around the World

20 Creepiest Abandoned Hospitals From Around the World

Hospitals can be scary places. They’re sterile and often impersonal, and oh yeah, there are often people dying all around you. And let’s not even get into the fact that...

7 Weird Ways People Try to Get Drunk

7 Weird Ways People Try to Get Drunk

People like their booze, and have for centuries upon centuries. It’s not a secret that basically as long as there have been human beings roaming the Earth, there have been human...

8 Ways Science Says Sex Is the Best Medicine

8 Ways Science Says Sex Is the Best Medicine

With a few odd exceptions, people love sex. Sex sells, people enjoy watching it, and more importantly, people enjoy having it. That’s because sex makes you feel good, and it...

10 Absolutely Baffling Celebrity Cameos in Music Videos

10 Absolutely Baffling Celebrity Cameos in Music Videos

Believe it or not, music videos are actually things that still exist, despite the fact that channels like MTV would have you believe otherwise. Celebrities popping up in a music...

7 TV and Movie Side Characters That Deserve Their Own Spinoffs

7 TV and Movie Side Characters That Deserve Their Own Spinoffs

One of the hardest things about writing fiction is coming up with interesting, fully developed side characters. After all, you can’t spend too much time on them because you...

8 Incredible Facts About Game of Thrones

8 Incredible Facts About Game of Thrones

Game of Thrones is an absolute juggernaut. There’s no denying it. Along with Walking Dead, you’d be hard pressed to find a television show that gets more online chatter that...

7 Books That Should Would Make Great TV Shows

7 Books That Should Would Make Great TV Shows

With the return of the immensely successful and wildly popular Game of Thrones, it’s only natural to look at the bookshelf and imagine what books may have a chance to rival the...

8 Completely Off the Wall Zombie Movies

8 Completely Off the Wall Zombie Movies

First things first, let’s not pretend that zombie movies are ever going to be exactly “normal.” After all, we’re talking about movies that center on the conceit that the...